Searching a definition for blogs

By    John Garner on  Friday, April 14, 2006
Summary: I have only started blogging recently, even though I have been building web sites for nearly twelve years. What I find interesting about blogs is how people define them. I have tried to define blogs in two distinctive ways : A (1 to 13) : from a functional and technical perspective B (1 to 7) […]

I have only started blogging recently, even though I have been building web sites for nearly twelve years.

What I find interesting about blogs is how people define them.
I have tried to define blogs in two distinctive ways :
A (1 to 13) : from a functional and technical perspective
B (1 to 7) : from a conceptual and more emotional perspective

Main characteristics :
A1 Title, each article/post/note has a title
A2 Date (optionally time), each article/post/note has an indication of when it was created.
A3 Content/Body, each article/post/note has content that is the main body, however it is possible that title and content be the same length in certain cases.
A4 Comments, each article/post/note allows users to post comments. Some systems have central user authentication systems that will recognize users and authenticate them so they can post as a recognized user.
A5 Permalink, each article/post/note has a specific URL/address that will display the article/post/note in full and generally followed by the comments

Common Options :
A5 Author, articles/posts/notes will have an indication of the name of the author or a nickname/handle of the author
A7 Categories/Tags, when each article/post/note is created, the creator usually can indicate which categories/tags it is associated with.
A8 Trackback, blogs are precursors in this area, the trackback is basically an automated communication system that will inform another blog/system that a message has been posted about an article/post/note. When an article/post/note is written on blog A about something on blog B, blog A automatically pings blog B to inform it.
A9 Archives, blogs usually have links to archives and or previous articles/posts/notes sorted by months
A10 Order, blog comments are usually displayed after the article/post/note, in reverse chronological order (the most recent is displayed first)

Back-end Functions :
A11 Users or groups of users will be authenticated and thus gain access to a type of dashboard that will allow them to create and often preview before publishing the article/post/note.
A12 Categories/Tags and Pages and of course the articles/posts/notes can be managed using a WYSIWIG or form based system like the articles/posts/notes
A13 Themes and Plugins, Blog systems allow bloggers to heavily customize/personalize the look and feel of their blogs as well as adding specific functions like contact pages, photo galleries etc.

Conceptual and Emotional Perspectives :
B1 Opinions, blogs are often defined as being personal accounts/diaries/journals
B2 Theme, blogs and the content often have a central underlying theme
B3 Types, blogs are often professional or personal and sometimes group based
B4 Discussion, blogging is closely associated with the idea of discussion via the concept of posting comments about the article/post/note
B5 Personal, blogs often present themselves as the work of a person or a group of people and do so with an about page and more often than not with a photo. This instantly gives personality and creates a link/bond with the writer that is often lacking in many online newspapers/magazines.
B6 Free, on a par with the founding spirit of the Internet, blogs are so far, in the vast majority, free to create and use. This is one of the nice sides of blogging in that it resembles a large freedom of speech movement. Specific and extra user needs like having your own domain name are obviously available at a price...
B7 Easy to use, blogs do not really require knowledge of any programming language and each new version of the most well known systems makes things easier and bring new interesting functions to the blogging world. A lot of networking functions like trackback to inform others of what you have posted are automatically handled without any user intervention required.

What Blogs are not :
Forums are not usually like blogs. In a forum multiple users can post articles/content and multiple users can post comments. When following a thread of posts in a forum it is often difficult to differentiate between the first post and the following posts. It would be possible to set-up a forum whereby the initial message in a thread could only be posted by a specific user or group of users and only then could others respond, however this is not how forums are traditionally set-up. Unlike blogs where discussions evolve from one point, forums allow multiple starting points for discussion. Blogs also seem to link more between each other and between posts/notes than forums do.

Newsgroups are pretty different to blogs. Newsgroups are not only different in form but also technically in the way they work. Groups on newsgroups are replicated over multiple servers all over the world which rarely happens with blogs in fact I don't know of an example. Newsgroups are just messages posted to a specific group and depending on the software used to read the messages links and/or associations between messages can be hard to figure out unlike in forums. There is no real structure in commenting on an initial post in newsgroups since links between posts are not that easy to establish. Newsgroups are also well known for multi-part binary posts of images, video and all sorts of other file formats on top of text messages.

CMS, I've worked on creating web sites using Content Management Systems (CMS) like Vignette StoryServer and recently Gossamer Threads Links (can be considered a CMS). With this experience in mind I tend to disagree with most blog fanatics in their will to differentiate themselves with CMS systems. There is no real need to debate here, professional CMS software is capable, when properly configured, to provide everything blogs provide, and more (hence the extra cost involved).
Most CMS can be set-up to look and work exactly like blogs. From this point onwards blog fanatics tend to turn to the quoted conceptual and more emotional definition of a blog to argue differences between a CMS and blogs which can obviously also be replicated...

Blog Trivia :
One of the first bloggers Justin Hall started with a site called
Web log was first used in 1997 by Jorn Barger and was first shortened to blog in 1999 by Peter Merholz
Open Diary first started the article with comments system in 1998

Article written by  John Garner

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment on “Searching a definition for blogs”

  1. For my part blogs (bloggers) like writers and journalists alike are interesting and valuable when they write nicely, with personality (but not too much) and the subject(s) is/are interesting. Hence seeing good bloggers (blogs) being offered jobs as journalists or TV presenters etc. seems a pretty logical move…

    The success of a blog is also a reflection of society to a certain extent in that I will find certain blogs uninteresting, not funny and consistently vulgar that you may really like. The diversity of blogs available is incredible providing a wealth of content to choose from. I have come across bloggers that are incapable of laughing about themselves but easily at others, disrespectful of other countries, cultures, races etc. (I'll stop here with my list of condolences) but this is not exclusive to blogs since it is the same with newspapers and on TV…

    As they say in French “Il faut de tout pour faire un monde” A bit of everything is needed to make a world

    I do have a hard time with the blog fanatics who will be scornful about content that is not published in a so called blog format. This sort of snobby elitist approach that would have you believe that the channel used to distribute, somehow increases the quality of the content is ridiculous.

    But some blogs are just so great, fun, nicely written, interesting that you forget about the bad eggs by the end of the day

Recent Posts

Check out the most recent posts from the blog: 
Sunday, September 24, 2023
The reliability & accuracy of GenAI

I question the reliability and accuracy of Generative AI (GenAI) in enterprise scenarios, particularly when faced with adversarial questions, highlighting that current Large Language Models (LLMs) may be data-rich but lack in reasoning and causality. I would call for a more balanced approach to AI adoption in cases of assisting users, requiring supervision, and the need for better LLM models that can be trusted, learn, and reason.

Read More
Saturday, September 23, 2023
From Chatbots to Reducing Society's Technical Debt

I discuss my experience with chatbots, contrasting older rules-based systems with newer GenAI (General Artificial Intelligence) chatbots. We cannot dismiss the creative capabilities of GenAI-based chatbots, but these systems lack reliability, especially in customer-facing applications, and improvements in the way AI is structured could lead to a "software renaissance," potentially reducing society's technical debt.

Read More
Friday, June 16, 2023
The imbalance of power in the AI game: in search of the common good

The article discusses the contrasting debate on how AI safety is and should be managed, its impact on technical debt, and its societal implications.
It notes the Center for AI Safety's call for a worldwide focus on the risks of AI, and Meredith Whittaker's criticism that such warnings preserve the status quo, strengthening tech giants' dominance. The piece also highlights AI's potential to decrease societal and technical debt by making software production cheaper, simpler, and resulting in far more innovation. It provides examples of cost-effective open-source models that perform well and emphasizes the rapid pace of AI innovation. Last, the article emphasises the need for adaptive legislation to match the pace of AI innovation, empowering suitable government entities for oversight, defining appropriate scopes for legislation and regulation, addressing ethical issues and biases in AI, and promoting public engagement in AI regulatory decisions.

Read More
Thursday, June 1, 2023
Japan revises copyright laws for AI

Japan has made its ruling on the situation between Content creators and Businesses. Japanese companies that use AI have the freedom to use content for training purposes without the burden of copyright laws. This news about the copyright laws in Japan reported over at Technomancers is seen as Businesses: 1 / Content Creators: 0 The […]

Read More